- Michelin GuideGurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater SpaMontauk7.9
- Cayuga Street Sunshine RetreatOcean Bay Park9.0
- Surfside Retreat On Champlain StreetOcean Bay Park8.6
- Harpoon HouseSouthampton8.6
- Charming Hampton Bays Home 5 Mi to Coopers BeachHampton Bays7.7
- Seaside Escape on HuronOcean Beach
- Classic Southold Country CharmerSouthold10.0
- North Fork Waterfront GemEast Marion
- Rocky Point Escape with Grill - 1 Mi to the Beach!Rocky Point9.6
- Aria & Mare HamptonsHampton Bays9.6
- Poolside Chic by the SeaOcean Bay Park5.0
- Michelin GuideBaron's CoveSag Harbor8.7
- Michelin GuideParrish Art MuseumSouthampton
- Michelin GuideThe Montauk Beach HouseMontauk8.6
- Michelin GuideShore Line Trolley MuseumEast Haven
- End of results -