- The Hermitage at Napeague8.7Amagansett
- Sole East Beach5.7Montauk
- East Hampton Art House Bed and BreakfastEast Hampton9.8
- The HomesteadMadison9.5
- American Beech Hotel8.9Greenport
- Villa KeyLimeSag Harbor
- Villa PerlmanSouthampton
- Villa LalamSouthampton
- The Madison Fire Island PinesFire Island Pines7.8
- Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island9.7Shelter Island Heights
- Premier Waterfront Cottage 1Riverhead10.0
- Beachfront Connecticut Retreat with Views!Milford
- Sea Haven Resort Motel5.0Southampton
- Bay Watch Hotel and Marina7.7Hampton Bays
- Waterfront Cottage 4Riverhead10.0
- Shelter Island House4.0Shelter Island Heights
- Premier Waterfront Cottage 2Riverhead9.3
- Clegg's Hotel8.8Ocean Beach
- Beach Plum Resort8.9Montauk
- Historic White Blossom House8.5Southold
- Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook6.2Old Saybrook
- Hilton Long Island/Huntington7.5Melville
- Hilton Garden Inn Melville8.3Plainview
- Four Points by Sheraton Melville Long Island8.0Plainview
- Southampton Long Island Hotel8.5Southampton
- The Pridwin Hotel9.4Shelter Island
- Topping Rose House8.2Bridgehampton
- Daunts Albatross MotelMontauk8.5
- Villa SkylarSouthampton
- Quaint DT Greenport Apt - 2 Mi to Shelter Island!Greenport10.0
- Mill House Inn8.5East Hampton
- Villa Charlotte - Elegant 7 BedroomSouthampton
- Villa Nostro PalazzoEast Hampton
- The Harbor Front InnGreenport8.5
- Bayview ResortHampton Bays7.4
- Sole East Resort7.2Montauk
- Rodeway Inn & Suites Branford - Guilford6.9Branford
- Apartment in Royal Atlantic Beach ResortMontauk8.1
- Windward ShoresAmagansett8.3
- Montauk Oceanside SuitesMontauk8.3
- End of results -